View Full Version: Anime Punch zine?

Neo Battle Peasant > Planning 2006 > Anime Punch zine?



Title: Anime Punch zine?


Chris - June 6, 2005 04:04 AM (GMT)
I had an idea. Not sure if it's cool/feasible or not.

Mike, you and I have long decried how easy fandom has become and regretted the passing of the age of vhs fansubbing and (paper) fanzines. What if Anime Punch put out some sort of zine that tried to capture the aesthetic of those days, when zines and newsletters were the way fans talked to one another? We could have articles, manifestos, maybe a short manga or two, etc.

Cons often talk about how their paying attendees are buying "memberships" in the con, which is often just a useful fiction (like fansubbers taking "requests" rather than "orders"). What if our con existed in some way for more than just three days of the year? In my mind, I'm thinking maybe two issues between now and the con (for pre-regs - one more reason to send us money now!), and one at the door.

Obviously, expenses (both in production and shipping) mount up quickly, depending on how long and how elaborate it gets. It doesn't have to be more than a few pages to raise the coolness of the con (though if it sucks too much - in a non-cool way - it could hurt the con). It's a lot of extra effort, but it may be worth it..

(Oh yeah - Hey everybody, I'm Chris, the video head, and I really should have been asleep an hour ago.)

pandad102 - June 6, 2005 06:02 AM (GMT)
I like this idea

Saishu_Heiki - June 6, 2005 08:52 AM (GMT)
I miss those days. Those fanzines were cool.

I would be willing to help with articles and such. Just let me know.

Chris - June 8, 2005 02:02 AM (GMT)
Some logistical thoughts:

I was thinking we should send out the first issue around August/September, a second around December/January, and the third would be in the registration packet at the con itself.

Printing should be easy and cheap enough. Shipping would be the major problem. Postal rates will pretty much determine how many pages we have. Plus, there's the expense of envelopes, and the actual work of putting together the mailing is not as trivial as it sounds. We'll need to keep track of addresses.

I think it'll be worth it.

Kaisermikeb - June 8, 2005 08:47 AM (GMT)
We can possibly sell ad space to subsidize the costs of printing as well.

Now, as for content...
Any ideas?

Chris - June 8, 2005 10:21 PM (GMT)
Printing and Advertising:

The only printing related cost that could be problematic would depend on what we want to do with the cover; postage is going to be the killer, and I'm going to research that over the weekend. We could take advertising, though that may make us ineligible for certain postal rates. Has anyone here been involved in zine production in the past? I'm not terribly knowledgeable about zines.




I've had a bunch of disjointed ideas about the content:

Name:

We'll need to decide what exactly we're calling the zine. I'm leaning toward simply "Anime Punch". In the 19th century there was a famous British weekly satirical newspaper called "Punch" (after Punch and Judy); the modern usage of the word "cartoon" originated in Punch. We could look at Punch for ideas for cover design - not many people would get the reference, but we definitely want those who do to come to our con.


Style and Tone:

We'll need to study fanzines of old, as well as avant garde "little magazines" and, aparently, 19th century British newspapers. I'm thinking of making it look like a pastiche; we could have different articles in different fonts and such. (Imagine dense, single-spaced quasi-academic articles next to more readable breezy fannish pieces, etc.) We might occasionally have our mascot in the margin making fun of the pretentious article she's next to. Etc.

(At one point I considered looking into printing with a mimeograph, hectograph, etc. for extra nostalgia value, but that looks hard, messy, and (these days) probably more expensive.)

I guess the tone I'm going for is that we're jaded, over-educated pricks, yet still pathetic fanboys/girls at heart, and that despite our "in-you-face edgy gritty hard-core over-the-top proactive*" attitude we're still open and accepting of everyone from the DBZ-loving middle schooler to the unbearably cool members of the hipster elite.

*There are more Poochi-style adjective I could squeeze in there, but not "extreme", as our con chair says we're definitely not going to be "extreme"....


Manifestos:

"There is a specter haunting fandom - the specter of Anime Punch!"

We'll need a manifesto or two. Something bombastic, putting fandom on notice that we're going smash it and make it anew from the pieces. Our program for the salvation of fandom could flail around violently, with our positions differing radically in tone and substance. Thus, we want "to have fun and eat lots of yummy pocky :)" and at the same time "to critically engage with the Japanese experience of (post)modernity". We could proclaim the Otakunization of the World and then yell at fanboys to wake up from their dream and reengage with the painful, gritty world around them. (We'll want an Anno quote in there....) Or we could have dueling manifestos.

I'm toying with names like a "Manifesto of Futurist Otaku", in the spirit of the undisputed masters of the art of manifesto writing, the Futurists. ("Pocky is not a food for heroes, and fandom needs heroes!" a la the Futurist campaign against pasta....)


Articles:

We should have a review or two, as well as other articles. We can take all sorts of stuff. I don't actually know as much about what fanzines tend to run; I'm planning to do some research on that in the near future. Of course, I love quasi-academic pseudo-intellectual stuff about pop culture (like you see in "Hermenaut", and various fandom "journals", etc.) Fanzines don't seem really well-suited to fact, news, or "reporting"; rather, you'd want more personal writing about interpretations and how one was affected by a work. (While I was thinking about this I remembered a meditation by Brian Ruh on "displaced nostalgia" that resonated with me. Not mentioning this for any particular reason.)

What else do zines have? Rants of various sorts, short fanfic (often tightly centered on illustrating some particular point), etc. I think fake advice columns have probably been done to death. but whatever. In future issues we might have a letters section.


Manga:

Ideally, I'd think we want two short manga, maybe one following the wacky hijinks of the con mascot (maybe we could have a contest to name her?) and another more serious, even experimental piece. All this depends on how many pages we get to work with and what our various artsy folks want to do.


Puzzles and Games:

We could have Go problems. Newspapers regularly have bridge problems, so we could have Yugioh problems for absurdity's sake.... Various sorts of contests, etc.

Craig - June 10, 2005 01:40 AM (GMT)
A message from the chairman to all those who pre-regged for the first zine. Maybe you can add the rules and guidelines of the con, staff names, etc. I dunno just a thought. Maybe even an offer to let people know that they can host a panel as long as they have pre-regged. From there they send in/email/post what they want to do then we pick and choose who gets accepted into the panel list (making exceptions for staff/guest hosted panels).

neilworms - June 16, 2005 07:22 PM (GMT)
Actually building upon Chris' idea for the name, why don't we call it Anime Puck as a refrence to the Japanese satrical magazine (with plenty of cartoons-one of the most famous covers is here though its not a good quality image) that derived its name from Punch called "Tokyo Puck". If you want more info on it, its in Schodt's Manga Manga book. Puck was a pioneering forum for Japanese cartoons in the westren sense after Ukiyo-e had faded away.

If we're going to go for obscure refrences we might as well go all the way...




Hosted for free by InvisionFree