I did not put Trisha, because then there would be no Fullmeral Alchemist. Sorry. ;)



Please specifiy who if you picked other.



Edit: I voted for the spoiler.

Go Hughes!!!

Greed, I need no explain

maes hughes....LOL

Hughes why because he died in a messed up way [not to mention he is one of my favs].

'Spoiler'. I'd save Hughes,too,but 'Spoiler' was one of my favorites.

Ehem...the "SPOILER" person.

Nina and Alexander. WAHHHHHHHHHH

Ehh... All of them. XD None of them frankly deserved to die, lol. Or atleast not the way that they did. All the really good characters die ;___; or they die in a crappy way...

Aside from the ones listed, I dont think the Slicer bros. deserved to die the way they did. Its not their fault that the homunculus forced them into a suit of armor and forced them to guard a stupid lab.... poor Slicer bros. And Anime Barry deserved to die, MANGA Barry on the other hand shouldn't have died!

I too believe that any of the characters should have died. But especially Nina/ Alexandra. Nina was just a baby girl whose father had a pretty screwed up mind. She was forced and made into a monster, b/c of her father's selfish ways and insecurities.

Even though in reality i feel no one should be killed because it's not the right of others to take the life away from another human being. It's just wrong. As far as fictional situations like FMA, i believe the deaths of the homonculi who were harmful and dangerous to the society was good for all. They killed the lives of thousands of inoccent people for their own selfish reasons.

Although it was wrong that the alchemist created them, so partically it wasn't all of the homonculi fault since they didn't ask to be re born into souless dolls. But it also isn't right that they killed off thousands of inoccent lives and started pointless wars just so they can once again feel the sensation of being human once again. Two wrongs don't make a right (homonculi's wrongs and alchemist wrongs) so they went too far by killing off so many people.

The alchemist did do wrong, but it is good that many of them survive, considering that they are human and the homonculi are just dolls, but you also have to consider that the homonculi had feelings just like human beings. I think that if they were good, and tried becoming a human by researching for a more compromising method, where inoccent humans aren't sacrificed, then they would have been able to live better and safer lives. But that's just my opinion ;) :lol:

Hughes.

And, 'Spoiler' also.

Homunculi are not Evil and they dont do wrong. It is the humans that make them think and act that way. So its not like they kill thousands of innocent lives because they want to, They do it because of INFLUENCE.

Dante influenced them.
If you influence them to be good, they turn out good. Like Wrath, he wasn't bad, but influence and red stones turn them bad.

...They're like humans. They are born neither good or bad, they are born grey. But the influence turns them to white or black.

Hughes, he is one of mi favorite peoples. and i really liked how he was always showing pics of his daughter to others, lol. ^^

NOBODY CARES ABOUT GREEDS FOLLOWERS?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
DORCHETE WHY!?!?!?!?!?
d*** YOU GLUTTONY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Why am I the only one who LOVES Barry?

If we're talking manga Barry, I'm with you all the way.

Barry: Missy sure is strong, by the way.
Riza: Don't change the subject!
Barry:...I really like strong women <3 <3 <3

Maria: Nhh...I woman has to be brave!
Barry: Good, Missy! Good enough for me to chop up!

Manga Barry ish awesome xD. None of the characters deserved to die! NOT DOROCHETTE AND MARTYLLL NUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!

x) I also think Marcoh deffinitely didn't deserve to die. He actually redeemed himself and helped others... poor guy.

+___+ We can blame this on DANTE! She did EVERYTHING!

Gluttony didn't deserve what he got! nuuuu! GLUTTONY!!! WHYYYYYY?!?!

WhereTS IS KIMBLEY!?!?!?! RAH!!! just cause betrayed greed! BIGOTS!! *sobs*

*SPOILER. cause i guess some people haven't seen all of the anime*


wrath killed lust but nobody ever rags on him about that! at least kimbley didn't KILL greed! blame Ed! d***!
*runs off sobing* i need to blow something up... *sniffle*

Scar.

They just killed him off for the Philosopher's Stone --_--

Greed, Chimeras, Marcoh, Barry the Chopper, The Slicer brothers, Nina (OMG NINA!), Scar, Lust, Gluttony...

yep, there's alot of them.

Well, if Greed didn't die, then Ed wouldn't know the Homonuculi's weakness and how to kill him.

Marcoh woul've been killed by Scar either way.

Barry should've died.....3 years ago.

But all the other people don't deserve to get killed off.

And why did have to kill Lust? WHY!?!?!?!? T.T -hates Wrath-

Hughes was a good man. They killed off a comic relief. -hates Envy also-

O_o

/end rant

I would pick *COUGHMOVIESPOILERDONTLOOKIFYOUHAVENTSEENITWRATHOK*.
But since he's not on there...
Definitely either Hughes or Nina.
(I voted for 'other' anyway.)

I think almost everyone would like to bring back Hughes from the dead. How he died and what happened afterwards was just so sad.....and Nina's death was a hit to a lot of people also [just not me].

Scar... Hughes... Greed... TT.TT

<< lust. she shall live on!!

>>
<<
yay xD

Was it just me or did Lust actually care about people unlike the other Homunculus?

she did, and yet didnt.. like when she killed taht man..that was SOOO cool, xD "your a mistake" XD !! >> she rules all..

You mean Lujon right....I always thought they did things when he was "Studying" Alchemy and how he could creat a Pstone.... And she did care about Al (a little bit) and Scar.

It is going to be Huges. :rolleyes:

lust *sniff sniff* :(

Hughes was my third favorite character. When he got shot I was like "Maybe Envy missed and hit his leg or something." Then when I saw the funereal scene I swore never to watch that episode again. *sobs quietly in corner* :(

The only people that deserved to die in that show (ok not the manga the anime) are the really messed up hom (Envy, Wrath, Gluttony, Pride, and Sloth) Colonel Archer and the billion or so soldier who died thanks to the Furher's orders. Oh yeah um Kimbley, Nina's dad (cant think of name memory block), ect.

lol

Hughes.

Wrath of course, but this a really old topic, and wrath didnt deserve to die, as seen in movie.