Here's a good review that was posted on the IDF forums :


Finally an OKC review this is from ficangel.livejournal.com:

QUOTE
Yay for Carly Smithson! I am not an Evanescence fan, but Amy Lee can belt, and when an artist tries her who is not up to the challenge, like Gina last year, it’s noticeable. Carly is up to the challenge and then some. I swear, if she doesn’t get a deal from someone, it will be freaking ridiculous. She rocked the hell out of “Bring Me to Life”, then came down to the catwalk, hunkered down, and started “Crazy on You” out real slow and sedate. Which made the insane high-kick that she did right when the song goes insane even more epic. She ended her set with “I Drove All Night” (Cyndi Lauper, not Celine Dion, thank God).

And seeing her outside after the show:

QUOTE
Carly was before Archie, actually, and: wow. Lesbian pass for that woman, full stop. I mean, I was having those thoughts when she was on the stage, too, but she is staggeringly beautiful. And I had heard that she had lost weight as a result of just generally being exhausted on the tour, but it’s really true about the camera adding curves that were not there. (However, if you’ve seen her set, and seen the top she wears during her set? We applaud Carly’s curves.) Whatever. On the show, in person, she is a staggeringly beautiful woman. It was a madhouse at that point, but I was still able to get her to sign the iPod cover and tell her that she had kicked ass that night.

From newsOK.com:

Fortunately, Carly Smithson was on hand to convincingly rock the crowd with covers of Evanescence's "Bring Me to Life," Crazy On You" by Heart and Cyndi Lauper's "I Drove All Night," proving that, if she wants it, she could commandingly lead a mainstream rock band.